Predestination in Islam

Concept of divine destiny in Islam
Part of a series on
Islam
Allah3.svg
  • Tafsir (exegesis)
  • Aqidah (creed)
  • Fiqh (jurisprudence)
  • Sharia (law)
  •  Islam portal
  • v
  • t
  • e
Part of a series on Islam
Aqidah
Silhouette of a mosque
Including:
1Salafis (Ahl-i Hadith & Wahhabis)
2Al-Ahbash & Barelvis 3Deobandis & Millî Görüş
4Alawites, Qizilbash & Bektashism; 6Jahmīyya
5Sevener-Qarmatians, Assassins & Druzes
7Ajardi, Azariqa, Bayhasiyya, Najdat & Sūfrī 8Wahbiyyah, Nukkari & Azzabas
9Mevlevis, Süleymancıs & various Ṭarīqah
10Bahshamiyya, Bishriyya & Ikhshîdiyya
11Bektashis & Qalandaris
 Islam portal
  • v
  • t
  • e

Qadar (Arabic: قدر, transliterated qadar, meaning literally "power",[1] but translated variously as: "Fate", "Divine Fore-ordainment", "Predestination," "Divine Decree",[2] "Decree" of Allah",[3] "Preordainment"[4]) is the concept of Divine Destiny in Islam.[5] As God is all-knowing and all-powerful, everything that has happened and will happen in the universe—including sinful human behavior—is not only known but commanded by him.[6] At the same time, human beings are responsible for their actions, and will be rewarded or punished accordingly on Judgement Day.[7][8]

Predestination/Divine Destiny is one of Sunni Islam's six articles of faith, (along with belief in the Oneness of Allah, the Revealed Books, the Prophets of Islam, the Day of Resurrection and Angels).

Since many things that happen on earth as a part of Allah's decree are bad/evil, "the will of Allah" can be divided into two sorts—the "universal will" (everything that happens, the subject of this article); and the "legislative will", what Allah commands human beings to do that they sometimes do not (obey sharia).[7][9]

Some early Islamic schools (Qadariyah and Muʿtazila) did not accept the doctrine of predestination;[10] Muʿtazila argued that it was "unthinkable" that God "would punish man for what He himself had commanded".[6] Predestination is not included in the Five Articles of Faith of Shi'i Islam. At least a few sources describe Shi'i Muslims as denying predestination,[11][12][13][14] and at least one Shi'i scholar (Naser Makarem Shirazi) argues "belief in predestination is a denial of justice".[15]

Definition

In Islam, "predestination" is the usual English language rendering of a belief that Muslims call al-qaḍāʾ wa l-qadar ([ælqɑˈdˤɑːʔ wælˈqɑdɑr] القضاء والقدر). As per the Sunni understanding, the phrase means "the divine decree and the predestination"; al-qadr more closely means "(divine) power", deriving from the root ق د ر (q-d-r), which denotes concepts related to measuring out, aiming, calculating, preparing, being able, and having power.[16] Another source states, that according to scholars:

  • "the divine decree (al-qada’) consists of the entire and complete judgment forever",
  • "the divine measurement (al-qadar) consists of the particulars of the judgment and its details".[17]

Maria De Cillis also states the two words have "Semitic roots originating from Babylonian and Israelite religious traditions that considered the world" to be "a replica of what had already been recorded in celestial books or charts."[18] (The name of the 97th surah of the Qur'an is known as Surat al-Qadr).

  • Taqdeer Arabic: تقدیر also refers to predestination in Islam, the "absolute decree of the Divine", and comes from the same Q-D-R three consonant root, but is of a different "grammatical orders and thus not considered interchangeable" with Qadr.[19] In Arabic it literally means ‘making a thing according to a measure’, or ‘occurrence of events according to pre-defined measures, standards or criteria’. It is found in verses Q.41:12, Q.36:38, Q.6:96.[20]

Scriptural basis

Quran

While the Quran is "not consistent" on whether human beings have control over their life or whether their destiny is preordained, verses supporting the latter predominate.[10][21][22]

  • "By no means can anything befall us [his creatures] but what God has destined for us" (Q.9:51)[22]
  • "He has ordained for you ˹believers˺ the Way which He decreed for Noah, and what We have revealed to you ˹O Prophet˺ and what We decreed for Abraham, Moses, and Jesus, ˹commanding:˺ 'Uphold the faith, and make no divisions in it.' What you call the polytheists to is unbearable for them. Allah chooses for Himself whoever He wills, and guides to Himself whoever turns ˹to Him˺."(Q.42:13)[23]

... and in particular God's control over each humans destiny in the afterlife:

  • "As for those who persist in disbelief, it is the same whether you warn them or not—they will never believe. Allah has sealed their hearts and their hearing, and their sight is covered. They will suffer a tremendous punishment." (Q.2:6-7)[24][25]
  • "If God had willed, He would have made you one community; but He leads astray whom He will, and guides whom He will; and will surely be questioned about the things you wrought." (Q.16:93)[26][25]
  • "Nor would thy Lord be the One to destroy communities for a single wrong-doing, if its members were likely to mend. If thy Lord had so willed, He could have made mankind one people: but they will not cease to dispute. Except those on whom thy Lord hath bestowed His Mercy: and for this did He create them: and the Word of thy Lord shall be fulfilled: 'I will fill Hell with jinns and men all together.'"(Q.11:119)[27]
  • "If We had so willed, We could have given every soul its guidance, but now My Word is realized—'I shall fill Hell with jinn and men together'" (Q.32:32)[22]
  • "God misleads whom He will and whom He will He guides" (Q.14:4)[22]
  • "The Lord has created and balanced all things and has fixed their destinies and guided them." (Q.87:2)[28]

"The Book of Decrees" (al-lawh al-mahfooz), is mentioned at least twice in the Quran.

  • "Verily, We have created all things with Qadar (Divine Preordainments) of all things before their creation as written in the Book of Decrees." (Q.54:49)[citation needed]
  • "No calamity befalls on the earth or in yourselves but is inscribed in the Book of Decrees before We bring it into existence. Verily, that is easy for Allah." (Q.57:22)[29]

A reflection of belief in the power of divine will is found in the phrase Insha'Allah, Arabic for "if God willed [it]", which is frequently used by Muslims when referring to the future, to qualify any predictions of what will come to pass.[30][28] The phrase obeys the verse:

  • "Do not say of anything, I am doing that tomorrow, without [adding], If God wills" (Q.18:23)
Suggesting free will

Some verses seem to suggest that humans have free will:[21]

  • "As for Thamûd, We showed them guidance, but they preferred blindness over guidance. So the blast of a disgracing punishment overtook them for what they used to commit." (Q.41:17)[31][22]
  • "And say, ˹O Prophet,˺ '˹This is˺ the truth from your Lord. Whoever wills let them believe, and whoever wills let them disbelieve.'" (Q.18:28)[32][22]

Hadith

According to one source (Alfred Guillaume), the "books of canonical traditions" do "not contain a single saying of Muhammad's which leaves freedom of action to man" (although he thinks "there are good reasons for believing that these traditions are forged at a time when the controversy was at its height ...").[6] One of the hadith where Muhammad tells Jibreel about the articles of faith, including "divine decree" is

  • It was narrated from ’Umar that Jibreel عليه السلام said to the Prophet: What is faith (Iman)? He said: "To believe in Allah, His Angels, His Books, His Messengers, the Last Day and the divine decree, both good and bad." Jibreel said to him: You have spoken the truth. He said: We were amazed that he asked him and then confirmed his answers as being correct. The Prophet said: "That was Jībreel, who came to teach you your religion."[33]

A hadith quotes Abd Allah ibn Umar ibn al-Khattab as narrating the hadith above along with the saying that:

  • "If one of them were to spend gold the like of Uhud (mountain) in charity, it would not be accepted by Allah from him until he believes in Al-Qadar";[34][35]

Another hadith encourages Muslims to "carry on doing good deeds", though it will not affect their place in the Afterlife, as they have already been assigned to either the Fire or in Paradise and that can't be changed:

  • Ali narrated that one day the Messenger of Allah was sitting with a wooden stick in his hand with which he was scratching the ground. He raised his head and said, "There is none of you, but has his place assigned either in the Fire or in Paradise." They (the Companions) inquired, "O Allah’s Messenger! Why should we carry on doing good deeds, shall we depend (upon Qadar) and give up work?" Muhammad said: "No, carry on doing good deeds, for everyone will find it easy (to do) such deeds that will lead him towards that for which he has been created." Then he recited the verse: "As for him who gives (in charity) and keeps his duty to Allah and fears Him, and believes in al-Husna, We will make smooth for him the path of Ease (goodness)" (Surah al-Lail 92:5-7).[36]

Qadar and free will

Conflict between

In orthodox Islam, almighty and all knowing God's control over what happens in his creation is absolute. "Allah has decreed all things from eternity". He knows that they will happen, when they will happen, how they will happen, and "He has written that and willed it".[37] This includes "the pettiest of human or other, affairs", not withstanding "the grandeur of God's cosmic role", (in the words of scholar Michael Cook).[38]

  • "He knows what is in land and sea; not a leaf falls, but He known it." (Q.6:59)[38]

But at the same time, human beings in their life on earth have the choice to do good or evil, are responsible for their actions, and will be rewarded or punished according in an eternal afterlife.

This poses the question, (raised by the early Islamic rationalist Muʿtazila school of thought),[6] if everything that has happened and will happen, including all acts of good and evil, has already been determined by God, doesn't that mean that everything a human being does during their life is only following God's decree? How can human beings be responsible for this, and even punished with eternal torment in hell for it?[6]

The question was/is not unique to Islam, and the debate over whether free will exists is not even limited to religion. According to Justin Parrott of the Islamic Yaqeen Institute, "it has been an important issue throughout history",[7] addressed by the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle over 2000 years ago.[39] Orientalist Alfred Guillaume points out the dilemma "has exercised the minds" of theologians of all religions "which claim to present" a god that is both almighty and moral.[40]

Moses Maimonides formulated an argument regarding a person's free will, in traditional terms of good and evil actions, as follows:

… "Does God know or does He not know that a certain individual will be good or bad? If thou sayest 'He knows', then it necessarily follows that the man is compelled to act as God knew beforehand how he would act, otherwise, God's knowledge would be imperfect.…"[41]

Naser Makarem Shirazi gives a similar example:

They say, “Does God know that so and so at such and such an hour on such and such a day will kill someone or will drink an alcoholic beverage?” If we say, “He does not know,” we have denied God’s knowledge. And if we say, “Yes, that person must do this, otherwise God’s knowledge will be imperfect,” then, in order to preserve God’s knowledge, a person is obliged to sin and obey God![42]

Controversy and danger

According to Maria De Cillis, "the apparently unsolvable conflict between the concepts of free will and determinism (or divine predetermination)" has not only been "a matter of great interest" but also of "heated controversy", extending beyond academia and the ulama and into politics "by virtue of the repercussions that this debate has in a social context"; (for example, when tyrannical and corrupt authorities encourage fatalism towards tyranny and corruption by pointing out that these maladies are "divinely willed and preordained").[18] According to Justin Parrott, "the idea ... that everything has already been decreed by the Creator from eternity— has troubled theologians and philosophers for centuries." And not only have members of those two professions taxed their brains about the conflict, but the "myriad of philosophical conundrums that arise" from the issue has caused some Muslims to experience doubts of faith. "Are we forced to do what we do, or are our choices meaningful?"[7]

De Cillis writes that the issue was so sensitive, that the

Prophet allegedly taught believers to abstain from considerations about destiny (qadar), calling it a deep sea, a dark path and God’s secret. One of the most authoritative Sunni intellectuals, the theologian and Sufi master, Abū Hāmid al-Ghazālī (d. 1111), reports in his masterpiece The Revival of the Religious Sciences,[43] the tradition according to which Muhammad ... proclaimed: “Refrain from speaking about qadar.”[18][nb 1]

As a result, the scholars emphasized that providence is a secret of Allah and that "going too deeply into it philosophically" will lead to "misguidance".[7] The creed of Al-Tahawi warns "that providence" (the seeming conflict of divine decree with human free will) is such a secret that even God's most obedient and holy creatures were not let in on the mystery.[7]

The principle of providence is the secret of Allah Almighty in His creation that has not been given to an angel near Him, nor to a prophet or messenger. Exaggeration (al-ta’ammuq) and debate regarding it leads to failure, progressive denial, and a degree of transgression. Take every precaution against that kind of debate, thinking, and insinuation.[46]

Popular descriptions

At the same time, incompatibility between predestination and free will is not an issue in many popular Islamic sources.

  • "Allah knows everything and has already decided everything that will happen. ... The belief in free will is essential in Islam. This is because, for Muslims, life is a test from Allah. Therefore, all human beings must make their own decisions, and they will be judged on those decisions by Allah." (BBC);[28]
  • "Belief in al-qadar (the divine will and decree) is one of the pillars of faith,[37] ... Allah has decreed all things from eternity and knows that they will happen at times that are known to Him, and in specific ways, and that He has written that and willed it, and they happen according to what He has decreed ... The belief of Ahl al-Sunnah wa'l-Jamaa'ah [Sunni Islam] is that a person has freedom of will, and hence he will be rewarded or punished. But his will is subject to the will of Allah, and nothing can take place in the universe that is not willed by Allah. ... (IslamQA, a conservative Salafi site);[47]
  • "God has foreknowledge of everything ... Even if the fate of man's soul is predetermined, he has no way of knowing what that fate is, and therefore it behooves him to strive for Allah's favor" (Thomas W. Lippman).[48]

Explanations, justifications

The 10th century Ash'ari school of theology, (which is still one of the main Sunni schools of Islamic theology), reconciles punishment in hell with the doctrine of total divine power over everything, with their own doctrine of kasb (acquisition). According to it, while any and all acts, including human acts of evil, are created by God, the human being who performs the act is responsible for it, because they have "acquired" the act.[49][50] Humans only have the power to decide between the given possibilities God has created.[51] Maria De Cillis explains it thusly:

In his attempt to illustrate the meaning of the verb “to acquire” (a word that is typical of Ash‘arite theology), [Ash‘arite theologian] al-Bāqillānī, in specifying the difference between a forced act and an acquired act, stated: “To acquire means that [man] freely performs his own acts by virtue of a [generated] power joined to such acts that makes them 'acquire' a qualification other than any compelled action … Such qualification of the action is, precisely, what we name acquisition.”[52] It was in relation to this specific state that the action led to reward or punishment. More specifically, although he did not credit human beings with the power to make the action good or wicked, al-Bāqillānī recognised that they had the capacity to act in such a way as to make their actions coincide with what God wanted or rejected, thereby conferring moral connotations upon actions.[18][nb 2]

The scholars of inter-islam.org explain that while Allah has "full knowledge of the individual’s actions; past, present and future", this world is a test for humans to determine whether they go to paradise or hellfire. "The notion that this world is a test warrants that the subjects being tested possess free-will or else there would be no meaning to such a test."[56] Since that test does have meaning, this proves the individual does have free-will.

Naser Makarem Shirazi response to those asking why God allows acts of evil that He, being all-knowing, knows will happen (see above), accusing them of asking the question in order to fabricate an excuse for committing sins. Shirazi maintains "our will or choice [are] also part of God’s knowledge", and compares God to a teacher who "knows that a lazy student will fail at the end of the year and the teacher is one hundred percent sure of this fact because of years of experience as a teacher", and who cannot be held responsible for student's failure.[42][nb 3]

Justin Parrott explains that "from a purely rational standpoint", it may seem impossible for God to have absolute knowledge and power over all action in the universe, and for humans to be responsible for their actions. Parrott quotes sahih hadith that our "life span, deeds, and ultimate fate" (whether we go to heaven or hell) are determined ("written by the angels") before we are born; yet after we are born we have the opportunity "to secure a good fate" by appealing "to Allah through worship, prayer, and good deeds". Parrott explains that while statements like these may seem "contradictory on their face" to us, that is only because "of the human mind’s limited frame of reference". "We have to remember that Allah" and predestination "exists outside of time and space, beyond the cosmic veil in the Unseen," so that "we are simply incapable of conceiving it with our limited rational faculties".[7]

Criticism

Skeptics have dismissed Qadar as unjust and non-sensical -- inherently contradictory. Critic of Islam Ibn Warraq complains that the "system of predestination" turns men into "automata", undermining "the notion of moral responsibility" and the justification for the harsh punishment of hellfire.[57] Other critics of the compatibility of divine destiny and free-will (Abdullah Sameer and Hanney Selim) argue that the feelings of confusion by Muslims over the issue and the discouragement by religious leaders of attempts to understand the paradox (that they experienced as Muslims), are simply because divine destiny and free-will are not compatible. Attempts by theologians to make them so are logically incoherent, not unlike the doctrine of the Trinity in Christianity.[nb 4]

History

Pre-Islamic Arabs

Based on what has been preserved of the poetry of pre-Islamic Arabs, it is thought that they believed that the date of the person's death (ajal), was predetermined "no matter what he or she did". A person's "provision" or "sustenance" (rizq), essentially food, was also pre-determined.[55]

Quran

The concept of ajal is also found in the Quran in several verses, especially one revealed in reply to criticism of Muḥammad's military strategy (go out to Mount Uhud to fight when Muslims were attacked in Medina by the Meccans) that some Muslims complained led to unnecessary loss of life:

  • "If you had been in your houses, those for whom killing was written down would have sallied out to the places of their falling" (Q.3:154).[55]

(The verse expresses a different point of view—that acts are not predetermined, but their outcome is—than the later theological position that God knows/determines everything that happens.)[55] The Qurʾān also speaks specifically of the supply of rizq, or provision being in God control:

  • "He lavishes rizq on whom He wills, or stints it" (Q.30:37)[55]
Qadarites and Jabarites

The question of how to reconcile God's absolute power with human responsibility for their actions, led to "one of the earliest sectarian schisms" in Islam, between the Qadarites (aka Qadariyah), who believed in total free will of humans (and who appeared in Damascus around the end of the seventh century CE);[59] and the Jabarites, who believed in "absolute" divine "determinism and fatalism".[7] One statement of the Qadarite school doctrine (Kitābu-l Milal wal Niḥal by Al Mahdi lidin Allah Ahmad b. Yaḥyā b. Al Murtaḍā (a.h. 764-840)) arguing against determinism stated:

  • God knows that men will commit crimes, but his (fore) knowledge does not impel them so to do.
  • God wills nothing but that which is good (p. 12) 3
  • Everything happens by the decree and predestination of God except evil works (ألمعاصى "disobediences")[60]

Ma'bad al-Juhani (d.699 CE), was crucified by the orders of the Caliph Abd al-Malik in Damascus. He was said to be the first man to discuss the Qadr (Divine Decree).[61][34]

The Umayyad, during their reign, took the theological position that God had bestowed the caliphate on them, just as the Qurʾān described the bestowing of a caliphate on Adam (Q.2:30).[55] Among their opponents were Qādarī who asserted "human free will in some form", such as that the good acts of any person come from God, but their bad acts (including those of God's caliph) come from themselves.[55]

After the unfortunate dispute between the Qadarites and Jabarites, Islam followed the middle path dictated by the Quran and Sunnah, "between the two extremes".[7]

Abbasids

Following the overthrow of the Umayyad dynasty by the Abbasid in 750 CE, the Qādarī movement "either faded out or was absorbed into the rationalist Muʿtazila movement".[55] The next two schools that felt the need to reconcile the idea of an omnipotent God (creating everything including human actions) with a just God (who does not hold human beings responsible for acts God, not they, willed), were the Muʿtazila and the Ashʿaris.[18]

The Mu‘tazili school argued that since justice (‘adl) is "the true essence" of divinity, "God can only do and only wishes what is salutary for human beings". (Based on verses Q.3:104, Q.22:10, Q.4:81.)[55] He not only orders people to do that which is good and forbids them to do that which is reprehensible, he abstains from doing evil Himself. The evil in the world comes instead from Man's/human beings' free will. Man (the human race), therefore, is "the genuine “creator” (khāliq) of his actions".[18]

The Ash‘ari school, named after for Abū al-Hasan al-Ash‘arī (d. 935), argued that since God is all-powerful, "he is the sole, true author of every action, good or bad", including, of course, human actions. Humans are "limited to taking possession (by way of acquisition – kasb) of the actions created for him by God". Having acquired these actions they are responsible for them on Judgement Day. Sunni Islam supported the Ash‘ari school (though not exclusively) and opposed the Mu‘tazili.

Modernists

Exponents of Islamic modernism, such as Muḥammad ʿAbduh (d. 1905), and Fazlur Rahman (d. 1988), follow the standard doctrine that God "has foreknowledge of human actions", but the fact that the future has been determined and includes evil acts, "does not compel humans to commit sin".[55]

Sunni view

Sunnis enumerate Qadar as one aspect of their creed (Arabic: aqidah). They believe that the divine destiny is when God wrote down in the Preserved Tablet (al-Lawhu 'l-Mahfuz) all that has happened and will happen, which will come to pass as written.

According to Maturidi belief, all active possibilities are created by God and humans act in accordance with their free intention to choose which action they follow. In this way, the intention precedes the created action and capacity by which actions are acquired (kasb in Arabic).[62]

Belief in al-Qadar is based on four things

According to two conservative sources (islamqa.info and Allah Knowing) belief in al-Qadar is based on four things,[47] components[63] aspects:[64]

  1. العلم Al-ʿIlm – Knowledge: i.e., that Allah knows what had been, what will be, what has never been, and how it could be if it was; also what Allah says. He also knows what His creation will do, by virtue of His eternal knowledge, including their choices that will take place.
  2. كتابة Kitabat – Writing: i.e., that Allah has written every thing that exists including the destiny of all creatures in al-Lawhu 'l-Mahfuz prior to creation. Also called Allah's "pre-recording".[64]
  3. مشيئة Mashii'at – Will: i.e., that what Allah wills happens and what He does not will does not happen. There is no movement in the heavens or on earth but happens by His will. This does not mean that He forces things to happen the way they happen in the area of human beings' voluntary actions. It means that He knew what they will choose, wrote it and now lets it happen.
  4. الخلق Al-Khalq – Creation and formation: i.e., that Allah is the Creator of all things, including the actions of His servants. They do their actions in a real sense, and Allah is the Creator of them and of their actions.[47][63]

Stages of Taqdeer (fate)

There are five stages where Qadar is determined and prescribed/sent to creation:[citation needed]

  1. The Decree of Allah that is written in Al-Lawh Al-Mahfuud before the creation of the universe. This destiny, written in the preserved tablet, is never changed and encompasses everything that will be.
  2. Allah made a divine decree after the creation of Adam. Allah took out all of the progeny of Adam (i.e. all of the humans from the beginning of time until the end of time), and asked them "Am I not your Lord?" and all of the humans responded "We testify that You are our Lord!" Then Allah decreed to them who shall go to paradise and who shall go to hell.
  3. The Life-time decree. This occurs when people are in the womb of their mothers, specifically 120 days after conception. Allah sends an angel to put a souls into bodies, and the angel writes down the decree that Allah has made; their life-spans, their actions, their sustenances (how much they will earn throughout their lifetime) and whether they will be dwellers of paradise or a dwellers of hell.[65]
  4. The yearly decree. This is during the Night of Qadr (Night of Decree) where Allah sends down his decrees from heaven to earth, in it he destines the actions (deeds, sustenance, births, deaths, etc.) of creation for the next year. The word Qadar should not be confused with Qadr; Qadar is destiny, Qadr is that which has been destined, i.e. decree, thus the translation – Night of Decree.
  5. The Daily Decree. Allah decrees the daily actions of his creation.

An example of how these categorizations help clear the idea of destiny is as follows: It is possible that Allah sends a daily/yearly decree dictating that a person will make a profit. However, due to that person's good deeds (for instance, fulfilling the ties of kinship [being good to your relatives and maintaining the relationship]), Allah sends another decree increasing that person's profit. The reversal of the two decrees is all within Allah's knowledge and is recorded in the Preserved Tablet. The person himself knows nothing of his own destiny or of Allah's decrees, but what he does know is that if he performs certain good deeds, then He will increase his profit (as in the example above) more than if he does not do that deed.[citation needed]

Shi'a view

Shi'i Twelvers, along with other Shia sects, such as the Zaydis, reject predestination.[11][12][13][14] This belief is further emphasized by the Shia concept of Bada', which states that God has not set a definite course for human history. Instead, God may alter the course of human history as God sees fit.

However, according to Encyclopedia.com (drawing from W. Montgomery Watt and Asma Afsaruddin), contemporary Imāmīs, aka Twelver Shi'a, "in general, subscribe to the doctrine of divine determination with a nod in the direction of free will; Ismāʿīlī views are not dissimilar. The Zaydī Shīʿī are closer to the Muʿtazilah in their views".[55]

Some positions taken by leading Shi'i scholars (quotes from Maria De Cillis) include:

  • “Neither absolute compulsion, nor absolute delegation but something in between”, (lā jabr wa-lā tafwīd wa lākin amr bayn amrayn). Attributed to The sixth imam of Twelver Shi'i, Ja‘far al-Sādiq (d. 765).[18]
  • "human actions are created by God and can "simultaneously" be classified as free actions" and divinely "obligatory actions".[18]
    • Free unless someone had forced the person to do them, and obligatory because they "proceeded from a cause produced by God". Hisham ibn al-Hakam, a companion of Ja‘far al-Sādiq and also a scholar.[18]
    • This position was adopted by the Qom’s theological school and the Shi'i hadith scholar al-Kulaynī (d. 941),[18]
  • God can not "be deemed either the creator of actions or the One wishing wicked human actions". Sheikh al-Mufīd (d. 1022), member of Baghdad’s Imamite school.[18]

The idea of "a tablet" with the future written on it is not unique to Sunni Islam as one Twelver Shi'i scholar (Al-Shaykh Al-Mufid d.1022), claiming that "the Tablet is the Book of Almighty Allah in which He has written all that will be till the Day of Resurrection".[66]

To show that there is no contradiction between being predestined, and free will, Shiites state that matters relating to human destiny are of two kinds: definite and indefinite. To explain the definitive one, Shiites argue that God has definite power over the whole of existence, however, so whenever He wills, He can replace a given destiny with another one; and that is what is called indefinite destiny. Some of these changes of destiny, thus, are brought about by man himself, who can through his free will, his decisions, and his way of life lay the groundwork for a change in his destiny as has been pointed out in the verse:

  • Truly, God will not change the condition of a people as long as they do not change Their state themselves. (Q.13:11)[67]

Both types of destinies, however, are contained within God's foreknowledge, Shiites argue, so that there could be no sort of change (badaʾ lit. "mutability") concerning His knowledge. So the first type of destiny does not mean a limitation of God's power; since God, in contrast to the belief of Jews who said the hand of God is tied’ asserts: Nay, His hands are spread out wide ....[68] So God has the power to change everything he wills and God's creativity is continuous. Accordingly, as Sobhani puts it, "all groups in Islam regard "bada" as a tenet of the faith, even if not all actually use the term."[69]

Iranian scholar Naser Makarem Shirazi asserts that "belief in predestination is a denial of justice", and that there is free will in Islam,[15] but at the same time (according to him) God has foreknowledge of everything in the future. He tackles the paradox of God knowing man will commit a certain sin, and man's free will to commit it by postulating the existence of a machine so advanced that it can predict the occurrence of an event some hours in advance.[15] Yet one would not say the machine compelled that event to occur; likewise, God's perfect knowledge doesn't compel man to commit sins.[15]

Ismaili

Ismaili thinkers such as Abū Hātim al-Rāzī (d. 934), Muhammad Ibn Ahmad al-Nasafī (d. 942), Abū Ya‘qūb Ishāq Ibn Ahmad al-Sijistānī (d. around 971), the Fatimid jurist al-Qādī al-Nu‘mān (d. 974) and the missionary” (dā‘ī) Hamīd al-Dīn al-Kirmānī (d. around 1021-22), "all contributed" to defining the terms qadā’ and qadar used in the Quran. Ismaili thinkers wrote that humans were not able to fully grasp the Qur’anic truths in their exoteric and esoteric essence. Human knowledge, therefore required "guidance of a hierarchy of divinely designated masters", including "the whole chain of Ismaili religious dignitaries and officials."[18]

See also

References

Notes

  1. ^ Justin Parrott also quoted the Prophet's warning. “With this I have commanded you? With this I was sent to you? Verily, the people before you were destroyed when they argued over this matter. I am determined for you not to argue over it.”[44] More recently, the Hanafi fiqh fatwa site IslamQA stated that predestination is one of those issues which God urges Muslims to "abstain from" speaking about "as much as possible". "We must believe in predestination, yet we cannot assume that our actions are entirely bound by it." Though "everyone's abode (for Jannat or Jahannam) has been written", because God "knows everything we have done", are currently doing, or will do in the future, nonetheless God has still "given us the choice in everything" we do.[45]
  2. ^ Malcolm Clark, (who taught in the Department of Religion at Butler University for 30 years),[53] notes that "al-Ash'ari's 'solution' will seem more like a semantic trick to than a genuine solution" to non-Muslim Westerners today. "But before you criticize" this attempt to reconcile free will with divine determinism, "remember that no solution to this perennial problem" has been "able to resolve the problem to the satisfaction of non-believers".[54] Encyclopedia.com also shares criticism of the reasoning of the Ashʿarīyah: "Other scholars, even Sunnī theologians like the Māturīdīyah, found the term kasb obscure and unsatisfactory and called the Ashʿarīyah "determinists" (mujbirah )."[55]
  3. ^ Similarly, Inter-Islam.org a website of British mosques, offered the following example: "... An appointment is arranged between two individuals. The first arrives before time and waits for the second; he then comments that the second will arrive late as always. He bases his prediction on previous experience and the lax nature of the second individual. This statement does not restrict or bound the latter’s ability to attend on time in any way, it is merely an assertion. Similarly, when Allah the Almighty informs us, through his infinite knowledge, of his knowledge of our precise actions and our consequent abode it should not be perceived to be a compelling decision against our free will, but rather only his knowledge of our decisions."[56]
  4. ^ Ex-Muslim podcaster Abdullah Sameer has compared the conflict of Qadar and free will to the Trinity in Christianity, saying that "... And I got confused as a Muslim. There is no real good solution to it. ... its logically incoherent ... You have a contradiction that's inherent to the theology, one part it says you have free will the other part says everything is Qadar."[58]

Citations

  1. ^ J. M. Cowan (ed.) (1976). The Hans Wehr Dictionary of Modern Written Arabic. Wiesbaden, Germany: Spoken Language Services. ISBN 0-87950-001-8
  2. ^ "Six Major Beliefs In Islam". University of Delaware. The Basics to Islam. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
  3. ^ Muhsin Khan, Muhammad. The Noble Qur'an. Verily! We have sent it (this Quran) down in the night of Al-Qadr (Decree)
  4. ^ "The Six Articles of Faith". Dar al-Ifta Al-Missriyya. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
  5. ^ "Qadar". missionislam.com. Retrieved 2016-03-27.
  6. ^ a b c d e Guillaume, Islam, 1978: p.132
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i Parrott, Justin (31 July 2017). "Reconciling the Divine Decree and Free Will in Islam". Yaqeen Institute. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  8. ^ "If things are decreed, then how can a person be called to account for them? 96978". Islam Question and Answer. 29 April 2007. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
  9. ^ al-Ṭaḥāwī, Aḥmad ibn Muḥammad, and ’Alī ibn ’Alī Ibn Abī al-’Izz. Sharḥ al-’Aqīdah al-Ṭaḥāwīyah. (Bayrūt: Mu’assasat al-Risālah, 1997), 1:79.
  10. ^ a b Guillaume, Islam, 1978: p.131-2
  11. ^ a b Need of Religion, by Sayyid Sa'id Akhtar Rizvi, p. 14.
  12. ^ a b Islamic Beliefs, Practices, and Cultures, by Marshall Cavendish Corporation, p. 137.
  13. ^ a b Religions of Man, by Charles Douglas Greer, p. 239.
  14. ^ a b Muslims, by S. H. M. Rizvi, Shibani Roy, B. B. Dutta, p. 20.
  15. ^ a b c d Shirazi, Naser Makarem (12 May 2015). "The Issue of Predestination and Free Will". The Justice of God. Al-Islam.org. Retrieved 14 June 2022.
  16. ^ "A e D". Archived from the original on December 8, 2011. Retrieved December 7, 2013.
  17. ^ Ibn Ḥajar al-’Asqalānī, Aḥmad ibn ’Alī. Fatḥ al-Bārī bi-Sharḥ al-Bukhārī. (Bayrūt: Dār al-Maʻrifah, 1959), 11:477. Quoted in De Cillis, Maria (22 April 2022). "ISLAM. Muslims and Free Will". Oasis. 6. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  18. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l De Cillis, Maria (22 April 2022). "ISLAM. Muslims and Free Will". Oasis. 6. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  19. ^ "Taqdir". Definitions. Retrieved 8 July 2022.
  20. ^ Hussain, Tanveer (5 April 2014). "PREDESTINATION AND TAQDEER". THE QURANIC TEACHINGS. Retrieved 8 July 2022.
  21. ^ a b Wensinck, A.J., The Muslim Creed, Cambridge, 1932, pp.51-52
  22. ^ a b c d e f Ibn Warraq, Why I Am Not a Muslim, 1995: p.124
  23. ^ Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran| Quran 42:13 Quran 42:13
  24. ^ Quran 2:6-7
  25. ^ a b Cook, Michael, The Koran, A Very Short Introduction, Oxford University Press, 2000, p.16
  26. ^ Quran 16:93
  27. ^ Quran 11:119
  28. ^ a b c "GCSE Edexcel Muslim beliefs. Al-Qadr". BBC Bitesize. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  29. ^ Quran 57:22
  30. ^ Esposito, John, ed. (2003). "Insha Allah". Oxford Dictionary of Islam. Oxford University Press. p. 138. ISBN 0-19-512558-4. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  31. ^ Quran 41:17
  32. ^ Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran| Quran 18:28 Quran 18:28 (first part of verse)
  33. ^ "Musnad Ahmad » Musnad 'Umar b. al-Khattab (ra) - مُسْنَدِ عُمَرَ بْنِ الْخَطَّابِ رَضِيَ اللَّهُ عَنْهُ » Hadith 191". Sunnah.com. Retrieved 14 June 2022.
  34. ^ a b tirmidhi. "Jami' at-Tirmidhi » The Book on Faith - كتاب الإيمان عن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم » Hadith 2610". sunnah.com. Retrieved 26 June 2022.
  35. ^ 431 hadith found in 'The Book of Faith (Kitab Al-Iman)' of Sahih Muslim. [1]
  36. ^ There are a large number of hadith with similar wording in various collections of hadith
  37. ^ a b al-Qada’ wa’l-Qadar by Dr ‘Abd al-Rahmaan al-Mahmoud, p. 39; quoted in "Is man's fate pre-destined or does he have freedom of will? 20806". Islam Question and Answer. 10 June 2003. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  38. ^ a b Cook, The Koran, 2000: p.19
  39. ^ Dudley, John. Aristotle's Concept of Chance: Accidents, Cause, Necessity, and Determinism. (Albany: SUNY Press, 2012), 2.
  40. ^ Guillaume, Alfred (January 1924). "Some Remarks on Free Will and Predestination in Islam, Together with a Translation of the Kitabu-l Qadar from the Sahih of al-Bukhari". The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland. 1 (1): 43–63. doi:10.1017/S0035869X00094806. JSTOR 25220438. S2CID 170696115. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  41. ^ The Eight Chapters of Maimonides on Ethics (Semonah Perakhim), edited, annotated, and translated with an Introduction by Joseph I. Gorfinkle, pp. 99–100. (New York: AMS Press), 1966.
  42. ^ a b Shirazi, Naser Makarem (12 May 2015). "The Issue of Predestination and Free Will. God's Knowledge". The Justice of God. Al-Islam.org. Retrieved 14 June 2022.
  43. ^ (Ihyā’ ‘ulūm al-dīn, Dār al-Qalām, Bayrūt, 1980 ca., vol. 1, p. 50)
  44. ^ al-Tirmidhī, Sunan al-Tirmidhī, v.4 p.11 #2133; declared fair due to external evidence (ḥasan li ghayri) by al-Albānī in Mishkāt al-Maṣābīḥ (Bayrūt: al-Maktab al-Islāmī, 1985), 1:36 #99.
  45. ^ "Is that a Muslim can believe in predestination, if so why judge Muslims? Answered according to Hanafi Fiqh by Tafseer Raheemi". Islamqa. 13 October 2012. Retrieved 5 February 2022.
  46. ^ al-Ṭaḥāwī, Aḥmad ibn Muḥammad. Matn al-Ṭaḥāwīyah. (Bayrūt: al-Maktab al-Islāmī, 1993), 1:49-50.
  47. ^ a b c "Is man's fate pre-destined or does he have freedom of will? 20806". Islam Question and Answer. 10 June 2003. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  48. ^ Lippman, Thomas W. , Understanding Islam, An Introduction to the Moslem World, A Mentor Book, New American Library, 1982, p.79, 80
  49. ^ Cyril Glassé, Huston Smith The New Encyclopedia of Islam Rowman Altamira 2003 ISBN 978-0-759-10190-6 page 62-3
  50. ^ GIbb, H.A.R. (1953) [1949]. Mohammedanism. Oxford University Press. pp. 116–117.
  51. ^ Hughes 2013, pp. 193–194.
  52. ^ Daniel Gimaret, Théories de l’acte Humain en théologie musulmane (Vrin, Paris, 1980), pp. 102-103.
  53. ^ "Malcolm Clark Books". World of Books. Retrieved 20 June 2022.
  54. ^ Clark, Malcolm (2019). "4.What Muslims Believe. Stating the Five Essential Beliefs of Islam". Islam for Dummies. John Wiley. ISBN 978-1-119-64304-3.
  55. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Free Will And Predestination: Islamic Concepts". Encyclopedia.com. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  56. ^ a b "Taqdeer (Fate)". inter-islam.org. Retrieved 7 July 2022.
  57. ^ Ibn Warraq, Why I Am Not a Muslim, 1995: p.125-126
  58. ^ 121 – Moral and Scientific Issues in the Quran and Hadith with @Critical Faculty, YouTube, Abdullah Sameer, video at 9:16 The paradox of free will in Islam. 15 May 2022. Event occurs at 9:16-12:30. ?v=TObHJK0BPrwt=9m16s. Retrieved 15 July 2022 – via YouTube.
  59. ^ Guillaume, Alfred (January 1924). "Some Remarks on Free Will and Predestination in Islam, Together with a Translation of the Kitabu-l Qadar from the Sahih of al-Bukhari". The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland. 1 (1): 45. JSTOR 25220438. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  60. ^ Guillaume, Alfred (January 1924). "Some Remarks on Free Will and Predestination in Islam, Together with a Translation of the Kitabu-l Qadar from the Sahih of al-Bukhari". The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland. 1 (1): 46. JSTOR 25220438. Retrieved 16 June 2022.
  61. ^ Sahih Muslim 1.'The Book of Faith (Kitab Al-Iman)' of Sahih Muslim.
  62. ^ al-Maturidi al-Samarqandi, Abu Mansur Muhammad ibn Muhammad ibn Mahmoud (1970). Kitab at-Tawhid (English Introduction by Fathallah Kholeif) Beirut: Dar El-Machreq. p. xxxiv-xxxvi.
  63. ^ a b "Belief In Al-Qadar (Divine Decree). The four components of Qadar". Allah Knowing. Retrieved 15 June 2022.
  64. ^ a b "The Four Aspects of Belief in Al-Qadr (Divine Decree)". Islamweb.net. 24 September 2017. Retrieved 8 July 2022.
  65. ^ "Hadith 4, 40 Hadith an-Nawawi - Forty Hadith of an-Nawawi - Sunnah.com - Sayings and Teachings of Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه و سلم)". Sunnah.com. Retrieved 2022-08-22.
  66. ^ Al-Mufid (10 June 2014). "18. The belief concerning the tablet and the pen (Al-Lawh Wa 'L-Qalam)". The Emendation of a Shi'ite Creed. al-Islam.org. Retrieved 20 June 2022.
  67. ^ Q13:11
  68. ^ Q5:64
  69. ^ Sobhani, Ja'far. Doctrines of Shi'i Islam. Translated and Edited by Reza Shah-Kazemi. London - New York: I.B.Tauris in association with The Institute of Ismaili Studies. pp. 159–163.

Further reading

  • Cook, Michael (2000). The Koran : A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press. ISBN 0192853449.
  • Frolov, Dmitry V. (2001). "Freedom and Predestination". In Jane Dammen McAuliffe (ed.). Encyclopaedia of the Quran. Vol. 1. pp. 267–271.
  • Guillaume, Alfred (1978) [1954]. Islam. Penguin. pp. 131–134.
  • Hughes, Aaron W. (2013). "Constituting Identities: Beliefs and Schools". Muslim Identities: An Introduction to Islam. New York: Columbia University Press. pp. 183–202. ISBN 978-0-231-53192-4. JSTOR 10.7312/hugh16146.13. Retrieved 1 November 2020.
  • Ibn Warraq (1995). Why I Am Not a Muslim. Prometheus Books. pp. 123–127.
  • Sobhani, Ja'far; Shah-Kazemi, Reza (2001). The Doctrines of Shi'ism: A Compendium of Imami Beliefs and Practices. I.B.Tauris. ISBN 978-1-86064-780-2.
  • Shah, Mustafa (2013). "Predestination". In Meri, Josef W. (ed.). Medieval Islamic Civilization: An Encyclopedia. Psychology Press. pp. 638–640.
  • Thomassen, Einar (2009). "Islamic Hell". Numen. 56 (2–3): 401–416. doi:10.1163/156852709X405062. JSTOR 27793798. Retrieved 6 January 2022.

External links

  • Concept of Qada and Qadar القضاء و القدر
  • Wrestling with Free Will: Reflections on Divine and Human Freedom| Mohammed Hijab |sapience institute |23 October 2021.
  • v
  • t
  • e
Islam topics
Beliefs
Five Pillars
Religious texts
Denominations
Economics
Hygiene
Other aspects
Arts
Medieval science
Philosophy
Other areas
 Other
Other religions
Apostasy
Related topics
  •  Islam portal
  • Category
  • v
  • t
  • e
Fields
Schools
Concepts
Philosophers by century (CE)
9th–10th
11th
12th
13th
14th–16th
17th–19th
20th–present
  • v
  • t
  • e
Theism
Forms
Concepts
Singular god
theologies
By faith
Concepts
God as
Trinitarianism
Eschatology
By religion
Feminist
Other concepts
Names of God in
By faith
Christian
Hindu
Islamic
Jewish
Pagan
Religion portal
Authority control Edit this at Wikidata
  • Faceted Application of Subject Terminology
  • İslâm Ansiklopedisi